By Jerome A. Cohen
Here is a recent attack on HK courts, by one of its most well-known retired judges. Henry Litton, formerly of the Court of Final Appeal, is a respected and able legal analyst who publicly called for the establishment of an independent commission to deal with the city’s chaos in the summer of 2019, a call that was not acted upon. Since then he has increasingly been critical of opponents of the HKG’s turn toward repression and implementation of the new NSL. Almost in tandem with former HK prosecutor Grenville Cross and former police investigator Tony Kwok, he has issued various op eds seeking to “reform” HK’s judicial system. It reminds me of the Mainland’s hoary admonitions that police, prosecutors and judges should operate like a single fist to suppress the opposition.
This op-ed goes further than previous criticisms. It condemns the HK appellate court handling the region’s first NSL prosecution even though the court made a decision that the pro-Beijing forces deem correct! Why? Because Mr. Litton claims that the judges should not have given extensive consideration to the constitutional challenges that the President of the HK Bar Association and his colleagues launched against relevant provisions of the NSL on behalf of the accused, despite the fact that the judges ended by rejecting those challenges.
What seems to upset Litton is that the judges carefully considered and publicly commented on the arguments of defense lawyers who, he maintains, were “seeking to impeach national legislation in the regional courts.” This, rather than the lack of judicial clarity ostensibly revealed in the court’s judgment, seems to be what Litton mainly condemns. At stake is the legal power of HK courts to consider the constitutionality of a new PRC law specifically enacted for HK that cries out for invalidation in various respects. As Litton points out, the NSL itself makes clear that Beijing mistrusts the independence of HK judges, which is why so much propaganda is being mobilized to further curb their independence in various ways.