By Jerome A. Cohen
Here is a report on the outcome of the three days of most recent bail hearings involving the HK 47. Only 11 have been granted bail. Because of the unfairly restrictive HK rules against media reporting and commenting, we know little about the crucial details.
Why have some been granted bail and most others denied? In democratic systems judicial decisions must be based on reasons. Presumably the judge will give her reasons in a written opinion to be delivered in a few days. One hopes her opinion will really do so rather than merely list factors to be considered and then simply announce the individual decisions without explaining why the application of the various factors has led to the various outcomes.
Moreover, why did the Government give up its opposition to bail for four of the suspects? That would be very important to know for purposes of dealing with the many other cases.
Note that those granted bail “are banned from making any speech or committing any act that MAY BE SEEN as breaching the security legislation”. “May be seen”? By whom? Police or prosecutors? Eventually the courts? The NSL is so expansive and hopelessly vague that this is an impossible standard. Moreover, does this restriction include not only “subversion” and all other possible violations of the NSL but also possible violations of Hong Kong’s pre-NSL security legislation ban such as that on “sedition”?
The result thus far in this most recent NSL prosecution is that 36 democratic activists will continue to be imprisoned for many months and perhaps years while awaiting the conclusion of their cases, even though it is quite possible, if HK judges and defense lawyers can maintain their independence, that they will eventually be acquitted! Moreover, all those who have been granted bail have been silenced and neutered for this entire period even though they too may be acquitted.
Is it any wonder that those Hong Kongers opposed to the NSL who have not yet been prosecuted have in many – not all – cases been silenced too? Unless, of course, they have managed to flee abroad.